
November 15, 2026
Good morning!
I’ve finally landed on a name for my sermon: “Notes of Another Third Servant” This reflects the final process of creation of this sermon. Earlier this week, I thought I had an almost-finished draft ready, but the closer I got to the end, the harder it was becoming for me to actually finish it. At last, I realized I hadn’t made my way deep enough into what was actually in the passage to be found: and I realized that I had a real desire to work more toward understanding the third servant in the parable. And in fact, that might mean going back to argue with the entire passage.
Finding myself arguing with scripture isn’t a bad thing for me. I’ve spoken before about how I see my husband Steve as my first partner in interspirituality, and this is definitely true around this capacity for arguing with texts. It’s been an important aspect of Jewish culture for many centuries. Jewish culture, in its scriptures and teachings, and even in its conversations around the table, are filled with this kind of back-and-forth in the service of getting clearer or becoming wiser.
When we lived in Austin, Steve and I hosted a small group, half of whose members were Jewish and the other half of whom were Christian. Our semi-regular meetings were in the tradition of Jewish study groups called havurah. We would read a passage in scripture together, and then begin a discussion that could go in many directions, but never farther than could be linked back to some part of the scripture that we had read together. These discussions embodied the importance of really taking the language seriously, and discussing ideas freely, without any sense of having to reach any sort of solution.
Both the discussions around family tables and in havurot circles could get quite lively, and sometimes considerably loud, as people brought love for the scripture mixed together with the passion of each one’s opinions. But though these discussions might have sounded contentious to someone outside them, it was instead the sound of connection and enthusiasm.
Jewish scripture and teaching have always included parables, known in Hebrew as Meshalim, as a way of having these kinds of conversations I’ve described. Many of these parables have a structure like the one we heard today: “to what can this [thing I’m about to tell you] be compared?” The stories are often quite ambiguous: they’re set up so that there are considerations on both sides of the equation. They aren’t meant to be solved, necessarily: they’re meant as invitations to a closer look.
That was certainly true of the parable, (in Hebrew, “Mashal”) we heard last week: that of ten individuals waiting for the arrival of the outrageously late host. Last week, after the sermon, we had the kind of lively discussion about the story that I’ve been describing. And I, for one, was still having the inner exploration going on in my head days afterward.
I learned in our havurah way back in Austin, and believe now, that when looking at parables, it’s important to try to put ourselves in the place of those hearing them in the times they were created. With Jesus’ parables, this means getting some sense of the specific historical context: the original location, the particular occasion, and a sense of the audiences that first heard it. And, at the same time, we want to be self-aware of the significantly different theological and cultural lenses that shape the way we read or hear the texts. But it feels worth doing: there’s a sense we might come onto something fresh and true.
It’s also important to recognize that when we read the parables as part of a Sunday lectionary, short passages are lifted out, and in the process, the setting tends to drop away. So I want to start with putting this week’s parable into those perspectives. Like the parable last week, Jesus told this parable during the period we call Holy Week. According to Matthew, after Jesus’ triumphant entry into Jerusalem, he had gone immediately to the Temple. There, he had overturned the tables of the money-changers–those who were buying and selling in the Temple courtyard. He also healed many who had come to him there that day.
Jesus returned to the Temple on the following days, and was teaching large gatherings there, telling many parables. He was also entering into increasingly heated exchanges with the Temple authorities and religious elders. This led, ultimately, to Jesus’ passionate condemnation of the temples’ legal experts and the Pharisees.
As he was leaving the Temple on that day, Jesus seemed to know he would not be back: it was as if he was fully aware that he was nearing the end in some significant way. Outside the Temple, Jesus wept over the fate of Jerusalem in the heartbroken way of one losing their children. He left Jerusalem that day for the Mount of Olives which is on the far side of a deep valley, but that overlooks Jerusalem.
The next day, Jesus was sitting alone on the Mount of Olives when a group of his closest disciples, perhaps the twelve we call apostles, maybe fewer, came to him privately to ask him about when the approaching end of the age he had been speaking of, and his own Coming again, would occur. It was then, on a hillside overlooking Jerusalem and the Temple with a very small group, that he spoke of many things, mostly in parables. The one we studied last week, and the one we are looking at today, are among these.
The Gospel passage for today is widely known as the Parable of the Talents. The heart of this parable is not very different that some others that Jesus had told earlier to the larger gatherings. The opening paragraph tells us: “The kingdom of heaven is like a wealthy landowner who was leaving on a trip.” He called in three of his servants, and handed his financial resources over to them, to watch them while he was gone. To one he gave five talents, and to another he gave two, and to another he gave one. He gave to each servant according to their ability. Then he left on his journey.
First I’d like to get clear about the money: I had no idea how much money a Talent really was! Other translations don’t use that term, but simply say that it was Valuable Coin. The Bible translation we use in worship puts the amount given to each of the three servants as $5000, $2000 and $1,000.
However, there seems to be wide agreement among scholars that five talents, the amount left with the first servant, was worth about $3.5 Million in today’s terms! The two talents given to the second servant equaled $1.5 million; and the third servant was left in charge of $750,000.
I choose to go with these astronomical amounts is that they convey the huge significance of what is at stake here. I think it’s largely accepted that in most parables, the listeners would make the leap from speaking of coins as money to using coins as a metaphor for the spiritual realities of our souls and spirituality. Whichever: the stakes are tremendously high.
Next, it feels important to contextualize the nature of the task that the three servants were being given. I got some help from Google in conceiving the nature of the assignment that the three were taking on, in contemporary terms. In sum, the persons were to providing Fiduciary Management of a Diversified Investment Portfolio!!!
We’re going to run into the limits of my knowledge of THAT very quickly. But just thinking about it in this contemporary way, and with openness to explore different meanings, (and also reading a parallel version of this parable in Luke), I want to touch, at least modestly, on the possibility that this is a story of a exploitative profiteer who is bringing in others to help with his questionable financial practices. Often, the crowds listening to Jesus’ parables would leap to unfavorable conclusions about the actions described as have money and/or power.
In any event: the two servants may have been working buying and selling for profit, or lending money. They would have needed to know a lot, pay close attention all the time, and also be okay with making a lot of very risky decisions.
This is not work that everyone could take on successfully: I, for one, am not made of this kind of financially detailed work; and I imagine that I would have felt significant anxiety from the instant I was confronted to with the task of dealing with someone else’s fortune—with an the amount that I wouldn’t have had for myself even if I had worked and saved for many lifetimes.
As I said earlier, I drawn to know more about the servants’ work as a way to learn more about the third servant’s behavior. First, I’ll look at the first 2 servants: as soon as they got their assignments, they “went to work doing business.” They obviously got right on it, actively pursued it and achieved great success: each of them delivered a whopping 100% rate of return on the amounts under their management. What an amazing accomplishment! The master was quite pleased: after all, his financial worth had been very significantly increased! “Excellent! Well done! You’ve each been faithful over a little: I’ll put you each in charge of much more! And come in, celebrate with me!”
And then all eyes turn to the third person. Recall that the master chose each of the three according to their ability: so there was something in the third person that led him to believe this person could take on this responsibility. Alas: It did not go at all well.
The third servant admits that he was afraid. And so he took what he thought was a responsible action: for a 1st-Century Judean listener, burying money was recognized as one of the safest ways to guard one’s own, or another’s money: it was an acceptable practice for that time. But the master was not impressed, especially hearing from this servant that the reason for their action was the lack of trust the servant had in the master’s business practices: his harvesting seed that others sowed, and gathering in crops that others planted.
Here, where the consequences get serious, is where I want to dig in my heels. I want to argue for a different result for the third servant: and, by extension, for myself and others who are or who have ever been similarly prone to fear and anxiety! Fear like this often comes from an individual’s experiences of shame or exclusion: ones that were painful enough that one’s psyche internalized the imperative to avoid anything that might lead to similar ordeals.
But the way this story ends is that the third servant experiences each of these traumas in turn: the master calls this one out angrily as an evil, lazy, worthless bum. And then when the master finishes speaking, he banishes this servant outside into the darkness, where other sorrowful, anguished souls are weeping and grinding their teeth.
I know there is a lot going on in this story.
It’s true that the first 2 servants operated from a stance of trust and then experienced success. But the third servant’s behavior reflects a lack of trust. And in an initial reading, it is easy to read that a stance that is defensive and constrictive results in a person’s inability to take actions that would have made them more successful. That may be.
And there are certainly times when decisions must be made that will not be distorted by fear. There are times when all able hands must be on deck, alert and in full readiness. Jesus is becoming increasingly aware of the dangers of his own situation: this is one of those times.
The third servant never does quite understand why he is being judged. And I have some questions, too. Nothing in the text compels us to think that the third servant is lazy: he may well have been acting constructively and possibly quite skillfully in other activities. For instance, he might have been one of those who is often sowing seeds, or planting crops.
So I’ll leave you with all of that, and with a question:
Jesus tells us at the beginning the comparison he is inviting to make: so, HOW is this story, as it’s told here, like the Kingdom of Heaven?
***
DURING THE OFFERTORY, you’ll be hearing a song that is based on a short passage from the work of Julian of Norwich, a 14th Century Catholic mystic who lived the life of a hermit. The singer takes Julian’s most famous one-sentence wisdom and crafted a wonderful and wise song around it. By happenstance, it has become the offertory song that you will hear next. I have found that it resonates well somehow with what we’ve just explored in the sermon. Please listen.
Note: Here is one link to the song, with words: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Kadbd3tCqc&list=RD_Kadbd3tCqc&start_radio=1